Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Michael Ruebcke's avatar

Agree on a lot of that, your direction is sound and matches independent data. But: “No click data for AI features” is imprecise because clicks from AI Overview and AI Mode links are counted in Search Console’s standard report, just not separable, only the dedicated AI report (since June 2026) is impressions-only. To be transparent I don't tell clients AI clicks are unmeasured but rather that they are blended.

An approach may load the CSV-only GSC AI report into BigQuery and joins it to page-level GSC totals pulled from the API (not the bulk export, which drops anonymized queries) on page × date × country × device. From that join it gets each page’s AI exposure share, estimates AI-driven clicks with a page-fixed-effects regression, and cross-checks that estimate against GA4 sessions carrying #:~:text= fragments as a lower bound, so AI clicks come out as a range rather than a measured number.

Utilizor Digital's avatar

A useful reset. I particularly liked the distinction between total search visibility and absolute keyword rankings — the former tells you whether you are actually being seen, while a single ranking can flatter or mislead. Tracking clicks and click-through rates alongside visibility in AI answers also feels like the honest test: it is not enough to appear, the result still has to earn the visit. I will be watching how the share-of-search comparison works in practice for smaller sites, where competitor data is often patchier.

Ready for more?